TURNING OUT TO TALK YOUNG
PHILANTHROPY AT THE FRINGE
For a third year, Toronto Arts Coalition joined forces
with The Fringe Theatre Festival for a panel discussion
on the arts in Toronto. A packed house turned out for A
Beginner’s Guide to Charitable Giving: Developing
a New Generation of Cultural Philanthropists, a
discussion about attracting and maintaining young donors
for organizations in need.
Judy Wolfe, a management consultant to the not-for-profit
and provincial government sectors, moderated the panel,
which included Sue Edworthy and Philip Hartwick from Theatre
Passe Muraille, Mina Cicconi and Elizabeth Hunter from The
Power Plant, Samir Khan from D-Code, and Anil Patel from
the Framework Foundation. Though all agreed that members
of the under-35 generation have expectations different from
their predecessors, many themes emerged on how to capture
this “experience-driven” age group. Here are
some highlights, capturing both concerns and solutions .
. .
 |
Generational Shifts
A significant difference between the older and newer
generations is that young donors do not as readily
understand the benefits of donating. Many younger
patrons have tighter budgets, having come to the workplace
with student loans and considerable monetary pressures.
Organizations need to nurture these younger people
to create a sense of community and connection.
Younger donors have also grown up with free access
to information and culture, via the internet. Though
this makes them more likely to donate online and subscribe
to email newsletters, it also creates a reluctance
to give money to general fundraising campaigns. |
Tangible Benefits
Anil Patel, Director and Co-Founder of the Framework
Foundation, an organization that advocates volunteerism
through creative initiatives, suggested that giving
doesn’t have to be an “either-or”
choice. Donating time rather than money is a worthwhile
compromise. For every $1 spent in traditional fundraising
campaigns, only $2 is generated. For every $1 spent
on volunteerism efforts, $7 in benefits is generated.
By encouraging what Samir Khan of D-Code, a strategic
marketing firm, calls the “participatory instinct,”
both the donor and organization benefit.
Sue Edworthy, Director of Marketing and Development
at Theatre Passe Muraille, recommended linking donors
to the purchase of real items, like a single pair
of ballet shoes, for a $50 donation. “Operations
is never sexy – specifics work.” Similarly,
Mina Cicconi, Development Coordinator at The Power
Plant, suggested working with this generation’s
“relationship with consumption.” The Power
Plant promotes continual involvement with regular
events and talks (such as those at the Rivoli) and
offers the potential of unique experiences for its
members.
|
 |
Creative Connections
Samir pointed out that the younger generation actually
donates at a percentage rate equivalent to its own
portion of the population: 25%. It is not that young
people are reluctant but the number of organizations
has grown and competition for dollars is high. To
be effective, he said, “Don’t discount
relationships outside the arts community.”
Philip Hartwick, Business Manager at Theatre Passe
Muraille also spoke about the need and difficulty
of collaborating with other organizations. Pooling
resources between theatre groups has so far been unsuccessful.
Long term planning is hard when it takes time and
organizations have immediate concerns.
The audience reflected this need for collaboration
and access to information. Finding out what has worked
for like-minded arts groups is elusive yet priceless
information. A warm thank you to the Fringe, panel
members, our moderator, and all who turned out for
coming together to bridge this gap! |
|
|